what the bleep do we know debunked
improve functionality and performance. Join the Cosmic Log corps by signing up as my Facebook friend or hooking up on Twitter. While many of its interviewees and subjects are professional scientists in the fields of physics, chemistry, and biology, one of them has noted that the film quotes him out of context. It's certainly not. Many religions and spiritual paths--from Hinduism, with its concept of maya, to Christian Science--teach that appearance is illusion. The idea that our own perceptions can't be trusted is not new, of course. Amit Goswami (PhD) in What the Bleep Do We Know?. You dont have a Christian Science Monitor [12][13] Lisa Randall refers to the film as "the bane of scientists". . As a series of scientists and scientist types take a wayward stab at explaining quantum theory -- it seems to involve being in two places at once -- "What the Bleep," which opens nationwide today . In the 1970s that abruptly stopped and moved to getting us off this planet. At some point I guess he updated it to string field theory and the version you provided a link for. Unfortunately, it also completely misunderstands it. Joe Dispenza, former Ramtha School of Enlightenment teacher, This page was last edited on 13 February 2023, at 23:23. It was an interesting idea aiming to solve the hierachy problem, as announced. A: Of course it does. Use these social-bookmarking links to share What the bleep are they on about?. What the Bleep Do We Know? Supported by groups like the Templeton Foundation, legitimateor more creative scientists are exploring the mind-body connection, or the similarities between particle-and-wave physics and certain religious concepts like the Trinity. He has stated in several venues that his views were totally misrepresented in the film. And while I dont think supersymmetric GUTs are anywhere near as promising as many people seem to think, they are a much saner idea than many that dominate research these days (take the Landscape, please). You can renew your subscription or But we're certainly using them at the Large Hadron Collider, which we couldn't even operate if we didn't have superconducting magnets. The reason you should be suspicious is because we don't even understand classical consciousness. Down the Rabbit Hole - Quantum Edition multi-disc DVD set was released, containing two extended versions of What the Bleep Do We Know! The part where the scientist put water under a microscope that was sitting under the label "I hate you" or "I want to kill you" Looked distorted and dirty but water blessed by monks was uniform and beautiful. It'd be like being the CEO of a massive company and having to listen to what every single employee was doing every minute of every day. The movie gives two examples of experiments which have shown the power of the mind affecting reality. There's nothing wrong with that. (stylized as What t #$*! It was really hard to sit through. The film has been described as an example of quantum mysticism, and has been criticized for both misrepresenting science and containing pseudoscience. D (k)ow!? And if you're a modern thinker you'll know for a fact that quantum physics is wacky stuff. 8. The film surpassed all expectations; it was certainly the stupidest thing I can remember seeing in a movie theater, and thats saying quite a lot (I see a lot of movies). and of course the big guy himself, Ramtha. It comes from the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, and it's about the limitations of trying to measure the position and momentum of subatomic particles this only applies to sub-atomic particlesa rock doesn't need you to bump into it to exist. We're not using either superconductivity or superfluidity yet on the scale that I think people thought we might. !" is a radical departure from convention. Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Hidden Dimensions, Rachels Musings Rabbit Holes and Other Oddities, Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Philosophy of Science on Blogginheads.tv, For "The Baby Goes Out With The Bathwater" Crowd - SLUniverse Forums. Sol. Dr Emoto takes photos of crystals formed in freezing water. We're such a shallow people. But when you get hit with so much information that's been edited to within a frame of its life, things get a bit confusing. This website uses cookies to What the Bleep Do We Know was directed and produced by Betsy Chasse, Mark Vicente and William Arntz, all of whom were students of Ramthas School of Enlightenment. is released on Friday. (Refugees in Sudan or people in Baghdad would have an even tougher time accepting the film's premise.). One other area where quantum mechanics works on a macroscopic scale is in superconductivity and superfluidity. "The protagonist, Amanda, played by Academy Award-Winning actress Marlee Matlin, finds herself in a fantastic Alice in Wonderland experience when her daily, uninspired life literally begins to unravel, revealing the uncertain world of the quantum field hidden behind what we consider to be our normal, waking reality. Simon Singh called it pseudoscience and said the suggestion "that if observing water changes its molecular structure, and if we are 90% water, then by observing ourselves we can change at a fundamental level via the laws of quantum physics" was "ridiculous balderdash". There appears to be no evidence to support this claim. Get ABC Sciences weekly newsletter Science Updates, The 'underground astronaut' in search of ancient bones, Voyager probes still signalling from the edge of the Solar System, Solar eclipses: Everything you need to know, Five ways your smartphone could help save lives, Chinese scientists use satellite to smash quantum entanglement record, Einstein's light bending theory directly observed in distant stars for first time, Third gravitational wave detection puts new spin on black holes. "Our brain receives 400 billion bits/second of information, but we're only aware of 2000 bits/second. (Source: iStockphoto). Interspersed with the plot were interviews with various supposed scientists with something to say about quantum physics, consciousness, God, etc. The following persons in the film have all spoken at RSE and sold books there. 5.Miceal Ledwith a clergyman with a rather dubious past (see http://unison.ie/irish_independent/stories.php3?ca=36&si=770458&issue_id=7565) is the one chosen by the film makers to be the theological spokesman. We may be able to use quantum communication in ways that we haven't done before. He points out that Gallo et al anounced that AIDS is caused by HIV at a press conference, without there being a single paper published in a scientific journal substantiating this. So far, so good. He says he is "profoundly unsympathetic to attempts at linking quantum mechanics with consciousness".[1]. But are there new, weird applications that people might see that have an impact on everyday life, beyond the woo-woo? My FIL is a ex-Air force Pilot. He claims that in over 5 hours of interviews he explained to the film makers why their concept of how Quantum Physics works has virtually no support in the scientific community. By clicking 'Send to a friend' you agree ABC Online is not responsible for the content contained in your email message. A disproportionate amount of time was given in voice and film to Ramtha, Dr. Joe dispenza, and Miceal Ledwith. But when animated, jive-talkin' human cells start dancing around in what appears to be the heroine's frontal lobe, all questions of spirituality pale before the sheer dreadfulness of this movie. "What The Bleep Do We Know? According to Joo Magueijo, professor in theoretical physics at Imperial College, the film deliberately misquotes science. Those points suggest that quantum-derived "possibilities" affect the wider world, that human thought is the ultimate arbiter of physical reality, and that by manipulating thought properly, people can achieve harmony and even shape the structure of matter. Your subscription to By continuing to browse the site She works as a free-lancer for an agency, where her boss is played by Barry Newman. asks nothing but . Use this form to email 'What the bleep are they on about?' log out. Despite his caveats, he recommends that people see the film, stating: "I hope it develops into a cult movie in the UK as it has in the US. As long as a sub-atomic particle is interacting with another sub-atomic particle, they'll both exist regardless of where you are or what you're doing. Free delivery for many products. Q: You do see that in some science . I had it recommended to me by no less than three people. What the bleep do we know debunked Isn't life great? DVD (2005) Marlee Matlin, Arntz (DIR) cert 12 at the best online prices at eBay! Adapted from "Ask the Everyday Scientist" with permission of the writer. "What the bleep. Quantum mechanics, the theoretical framework of contemporary physics, is a probability algorithm. A classic experiment on visual processing involves asking people to watch a video of 6 people passing a basketball, and press a button every time a particular team has possession. And wait-the human body is mostly water! You can't bring good things to you by thinking about them. A movie and a book said that water molecules are. Prominent if you go by citations that is. Water beamed messages of love or gratitude formed itself into lovely snowflake-like crystals; water exposed to the words "You make me sick" looks like the surface of a toxic waste pond. What the Bleep Do We Know!? The observer can't be ignored." This has led to accusations, both formal and informal, directed towards the film's proponents, of spamming online message boards and forums with many thinly veiled promotional posts. I guess it's a sign that quantum physics is entering the mainstream A: Well, yeah, the point is that there have been these new-age desires for lots of things to make the world better: crystals, energy vortices. It is true that quantum mechanics is extremely strange, and on extremely small scales for short times, all sorts of weird things happen. As he told ABC's "This Week" the day after the debate: "When it . So on one hand you have a threat to security, and on the other you have a possible boon for security. Directors William Arntz, Betsy Chasse Starring Marlee Matlin, Elaine Hendrix, John Ross Bowie Genres Science Fiction, Comedy, Drama, Documentary, Fantasy, Special Interest ?, never before seen DVD programming features, 20 minutes of new animation, new interviews, along with 5 hours of uncut interviews and a filmmakers Q&A, the Quantum Edition contains over 15 hours of material on 6 DVD sides. But no scientific discovery has proved so ripe for spiritual projection as the theories of quantum physics, replete with their quixotic qualities of uncertainty, simultaneity and parallelism." document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); WatchDocumentaries.com | Games | Quizzes | Contact |Privacy & Terms | Manage Cookies |Advertise | DMCA, Aleister Crowley: The Wickedest Man in the World. Featured individuals [ edit] The film features interview segments of: You can't just hope for the best. It demands a freedom of view and greatness of thought so far unknown, indeed, not even dreamed of since Copernicus. Categories conflate, confound, connect", "Our power is in our ability to decide - Can you? Everyone said that you have to see this movie! So I did. Some argue that the same quantum processes seen in the universe around us have an effect on consciousness as well, but physicist Lawrence Krauss says that's highly debatable. Andrew B Newberg, (MD, Radiologist), in What the Bleep Do We Know? What the Bleep Do We Know was directed and produced by Betsy Chasse, Mark Vicente and William Arntz, all of whom were students of Ramtha's School of Enlightenment. I think of what Niels Bohr said to Wolfgang Pauli about theories that are "not crazy enough to be true." If I didnt know any better, I would have thought it was something straight out of a Cheech and Chong movie. At the end of this article, Dr Simons invites readers to explore the limitations of their own brains. During the resulting chat, two men carrying a wooden door passed between the stranger and the subjects. But she is right about us not seeing things in front of our eyes if we're not looking for them. To some extent it could be, because memories and thoughts are stored at the molecular level, and at a molecular level quantum mechanics is significant. As the layers to her everyday experiences fall away insertions in the story with scientists, and philosophers and religious leaders . Hambling says it is likely that both the Hughes account and the story told by Pert were exaggerations of the records left by Captain Cook and the botanist Joseph Banks. What was new? Columbus certainly didn't speak the language, and the locals didn't keep written records. One possible answer: they go to an alternative universe where people are asking the same question: 'where'd they go?'" While Amanda waits for a commuter train, she (and we) are shown the work of Japanese scientist Masaru Emoto, who has photographed water after exposing it to different emotions. The question is, how far down the rabbit hole, do you wanna go? [7], According to Publishers Weekly, the film was one of the sleeper hits of 2004, as "word-of-mouth and strategic marketing kept it in theaters for an entire year." But it's quite a leap to say the brain doesn't know the difference between vision and memory. Producing, scripting, and co-directing the film, What the BLEEP went on to become a global phenomenon, with well over 100 million viewers experiencing the BLEEP. We'll never know. The bits and pieces of matter that make up sub-atomic particles (protons, neutrons and electrons) don't exist in any handy, measurable way unless they're interacting with one another. But most of the talking heads' quotes seem either to have a hidden agenda, or to be sliced and diced to buttress Ramtha's ideas. In one experiment, people who were walking across a college campus were asked by a stranger for directions. We all know most parts of the ocean are still undiscovered but there's plenty of theories. The observer effect of quantum physics isn't about people or reality. On August 1, 2006 What the Bleep! Dr Joao Migueijo is reader in theoretical physics at Imperial College, London.What the Bleep Do We Know!? Particles Popping Into & Out of Existence. Z. Knight and heavily features commentary from 'Ramtha', an ancient Atlantian general who is apparently speaking through Knight. You are free to comment as you wish. The sub-atomic particles that make up the atoms that make up the rock are there too. Krauss has dealt with factual and fictional weirdness for decades as the author of "The Physics of Star Trek," as the head of Arizona State University's Origins Project, and as the author of a "Quantum Man," a soon-to-be-published biography of pioneering physicist Richard Feynman. Our work isn't possible without your support. But it's not true for the universe at large. was heavily criticised for being "a documentary aimed at the totally gullible". Isnt Langs viewpoint in line with the sort of criticism that string theory receives at this web site? Initially, the film was released in only two theaters: one in Yelm, Washington (the home of the producers, which is also the home of Ramtha), and the other the Bagdad Theater in Portland, Oregon, where it was filmed. It was clearly time to check the facts for myself. The meditation may not have helped the victims of violent crime, but it did win Hagelin the 1994 Ig Nobel Peace Prize. Short Range Tests of Newtons Inverse-Square Law. Even so it notched up $10m in. The brain processes 400 billion bits of information a second but we're only aware of 2000 of these but our awareness of those 2000 bits of information are just about the environment, our body and about time. Q: Some scientists, such as Sir Roger Penrose, have talked about neurons as quantum systems. 1. According to an article in Fortean Times by David Hambling, the origins of this story likely involved the voyages of Captain James Cook, not Columbus, and an account related by Robert Hughes which said Cook's ships were "complex and unfamiliar as to defy the natives' understanding". Q: But isn't everything really connected? To date, there has been no response as to where the information which lead to the story about the indians not being able to see the ships of Columbus originated from. Happy Water Crystals Debunked as PseudoScience June 23rd, 2018 - Are Dr Masaru Emoto?s Fantastic Claims Actually Real Via is masaru emoto . The point is, with quantum mechanics, everything doesn't go. Right after the Velvet Revolution in 1989 (the collapse of the Czechoslovak communism), many new spiritual and other directions were trying to find their ways to the new free countries. This will be revisited if any. Pingback: yeago works Blog Archive Jesus, Buddha, Ken Wilber?? Around 650 million people watched the moment on television. Moreover, the movie proposes no plausible physical mechanism by which thoughts influence matter. According to his books, water exposed to loving words shows brilliant and attractive patterns, while water exposed to negative thoughts forms incomplete patterns. "I create my own reality, says quantum physics," intones one expert, and the viewer could be lured to accept this as proof. Check out this great listen on Audible.com. [19], According to Margaret Wertheim, "History abounds with religious enthusiasts who have read spiritual portent into the arrangement of the planets, the vacuum of space, electromagnetic waves and the big bang. But they add that the film shows quantum mysteries selectively to shore up metaphysical points. Is this a hoax to promote positivity? "What the Bleep" misses opportunities to focus credibly on the fascinating work people like Newberg have been doing, and makes the science-and-faith field seem like quackery. The fact that someone who spouts such utter nonsense can get a Ph.D. from Harvard and be one of the most widely cited authors on supersymmetric models is pretty remarkable. What the #$*! It demands a freedom of view and greatness of thought so far unknown, indeed, not even dreamed of since Copernicus. Dr Dispenza claims (correctly) in the movie that brain scans PET (Positron Emission Tomography) and Functional MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) show that the same part of your brain lights up whether you're looking at something or just remembering it. Dr Joe Dispenza and Miceal Ledwith are both long time students and appointed teachers at Ramthas school of enlightenment (RSE). The film "What the Bleep Do We Know?!" That would be, very hard to quantify:). On the other hand, one finds 3+1, or more concretely inverse square law, to be mathematically peculiar when it refers to gravity, ie when mass is the source of the force. Of Hagelins thousands of citations, how many are from the Ellis/Nanopoulous et al paper mill? kazakore (kazakore) January 14, 2010, 6:30pm #10 up and at each step we're eliminating information and finally what is bubbling up to consciousness is the one that is most self-serving. [5] Author Barrie Dolnick adds that "people don't want to learn how to do one thing. So does classical physics. It was the biggest bunch of garbage that I had ever seen. The quantum world does pervade everything around us, but as Richard Feynman liked to say, "Scientific creativity is imagination in a straitjacket." Gifted and talented kids: how do you nurture a curious mind. What the Bleep Do We Know!? They want suggestions, not formulas. Amit Gotswami What the Bleep Do We Know!? A group of 3 Indian people claiming to be direct disciples of Maharishi Mahesh-Yogi visited our high school. HCI president Peter Vegso stated that in regard to this book, "What the Bleep is the quantum leap in the New Age world," and "by marrying science and spirituality, it is the foundation of future thought."[5]. Unfortunately hes written no papers after 1995, see, http://www.slac.stanford.edu/spires/find/hep/www?rawcmd=find+a+hagelin&FORMAT=WWW&SEQUENCE=. In reality, science is completely incidental to the film's conclusions. A: Absolutely. This movie agrees with the scientists as far as the existence of the so called empty space is concerned. Q: Obviously, quantum mechanics has lots of real-life applications, including in your television set and your microwave oven. We hear more and more from JZ Knight, a woman channeling the ancient warrior Ramtha, a chap who (through Knight) incidentally leads the Ramtha School of Enlightenment. Featuring two (!) Hope you dont mind me butting in, just thought you might like to see these facts which are so far undisputed about the film. Not exactly, Amit. The pity of it is that there are fascinating conversations going on in the science-and-religion sphere. To accomplish that, you would have to invoke "new physics," Dr. Schumm says, in which the explanation can be verified or falsified through experiment. You can begin to be skeptical that the speaker is somehow trying to use quantum mechanics to argue fundamentally that you can change the world by thinking about it. You should be wary whenever you hear something like, "Quantum mechanics connects you with the universe" or "quantum mechanics unifies you with everything else." [14] Amongst the assertions in the film that have been challenged are that water molecules can be influenced by thought (as popularized by Masaru Emoto), that meditation can reduce violent crime rates of a city,[15] and that quantum physics implies that "consciousness is the ground of all being." While the movie "What The Bleep" has some flaws from a science point of view, science of this type is so foreign to most people, that they feel they have to "jazz it up" to keep people interested. Staff meetings are tedious enough give me a conscious mind with a decent filter device any day. If quantum physics baffled the late Dr. Feynman, one of its most brilliant explorers, then no one should feel embarrassed for failing to understand the subject. The figures are a bit rubbery, but the idea that we're only 'aware' of a fraction of our brain's activity is both correct and a huge relief. Thanks to Pylon Sentinel for pointing this out.A link to his Wikipedia page is here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Alan_Wolf And there's the matter of scale the brain lights up in scans much more brightly when you're seeing something than when you're reminiscing. Fred Alan Wolf, PhD in What the Bleep Do We Know? Doesn't the quantum world pervade everything that we see around us? What the Bleep Do We Know draws heavily on the role of the observer in quantum physics. If it's true, no one's been able to measure it or see the effects. Q: You do see that in some science-fiction shows for example, last season on "Fringe." In a corrupt, greed-fueled world, a powerful alchemist leads a Christ-like character and seven materialistic figures to the Holy Mountain,. Hambling says it is likely that both the Hughes account and the story told by Pert were exaggerations of the records left by Captain Cook and the botanist Joseph Banks. Filmed to promote a new age philosophy based on a very, very broad interpretation of quantum physics, the movie was funded by J. Miceal Ledwith A scientist debunks the claim that water reacts to human emotions. ", "What the Bleep Do We Know!? you are agreeing to our, One month free trial to theMonitorDaily, Staff writer of The Christian Science Monitor, Performance of quantum computer no better than ordinary PC, say analysts, 'Spooky' physics: How quantum entanglement could link wormholes, Quantum 'teleportation' distance record broken. But sounding like magic and being magic are two different things. "Physical reality is absolutely rock solid, yet it only comes into existence when it bumps up against another piece of physical reality like us, or a rock." "[3] It offers alternative spirituality views characteristic of New Age philosophy, including critiques of the competing claims of stewardship among traditional religions [viz., institutional Judaism, Christianity, and Islam] of universally recognized and accepted moral values. Therefore people get the notion that there's no objective reality, and that you can literally impact on the external world just by doing things internally. Isnt that a bit like attacking algebra because of Serge Langs nutty ideas about HIV and AIDS? Quantum mechanics may play a role at some level in the way the brain works just as it may play a role in photosynthesis. The debate here is that we'll be able to use quantum mechanics to break codes, in particular to determine the big prime numbers that are at the basis of the security of your credit cards and your bank cards. But I assume that's not quite right, and that sometimes quantum mechanics' name is taken in vain. I want to mention another point Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. All the weirdness of quantum mechanics gets washed out on the scale that we can experience. The movie features other proclaimed scientists who . This will be revisited if anyone else tries to circumvent a channel ban in future.PLEASE READ CAREFULLY:I'm citing \"Fair Use\" under US Copyright Act, Title 17 512 (g)(f), specifically those clauses covering Comment and Criticism, as well as the DMCA.http://www.aclunc.org/issues/technology/blog/asset_upload_file939_6218.pdfAlso \"Fair Dealing\" under UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 c.48, Part 1(Copyright) Section 79.4ahttp://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1988/ukpga_19880048_en_4Censorship is NOT a valid argument.This is the first part of my critical analysis of \"What The Bleep Do We Know?! First, such claims rely on "hidden variables" susceptible to influence, he says. Study Guide", "Teaching physics mysteries versus pseudoscience", "Review: What The Bleep Do We Know!? We will write a custom Essay on Philosophy Meaning of Arntz's Movie "What the Bleep Do We Know" specifically for you. Who believe, in all kinds of things(God maybe?). It's used as an excuse to be even weirder. And most thoughtful members of the "spiritual but not religious" camp would take issue if you chopped off their big toes and then responded to their complaints with a lofty "it's all in your mind." Do We Know!?) "Particles appear and disappear where do they go when they're not here? If you have questions about your account, please The Bleep in a Nutshell: 1. Present thinking on neurology and addiction are covered in some detail but,. Science and engineering are important for our future, and anything that engages the public can only be a good thing." continue to use the site without a If you wanted to study the impact of spoken, drawn or written sentiments on the formation of crystals in freezing water, you'd have to do a slightly more rigorous study.